Minimum standards and qualification required
Scoring Criteria
Tenderers should read these instructions carefully before completing the Tender documentation. Failure to comply with these requirements may result in the rejection of the Tender.
Price 40%
Tenderers are requested to supply “hourly rates” for the following type of contractors. We will calculate the average price for each category. With a score of 10% per category. Only provide rates for the category headings below – incorrect headers will receive zero marks.
Electrician cost for the first hour and hourly cost for any subsequent hours 10 marks
Plumber– cost for the first hour and hourly cost for any subsequent hours 10 marks
Tradesman first hour– cost for the first hour and hourly cost for any subsequent hours 10 marks
General operative / handyman : cost for the first hour and hourly cost for any subsequent hours 10 marks
Tenderers are reminded that the above rates should include an element of uplift to take into account travelling time and travelling expenses as these cannot be invoiced separately. Cost will accrue from the time of arrival at the property to the time of leaving the property. Timesheets need to be completed and countersigned by a member of Careers Wales staff for all maintenance visits.
Example of scoring methodology where Price is worth 10 Marks
Tradesman first hour £30, subsequent hour £10 the average hourly rate for this category would be £20
E.g. three tenders bids received – Bid 1 - average rate for plumber £40, Bid 2 average rate for plumber £60 and Bid 3 average rate for plumber - £80
Bid 1 would receive a score of 10
Bid 2
(£20//£40) 50% higher
60% - (60% * 50.0) = a score of 5
Bid 3
(£40/£40) 100% higher
35% - (35% * 100.00*) = a score of 0
Quality: 60 marks
o Previous work in this area 10% for each example – total 30 marks
Please provide three examples of similar work undertaken in the last 3 years – maximum 500 words per example
o Describe your quality management system, and accompanying policies, processes and procedures such as planned and unannounced spot-checks, inspections and audits during work delivery. 300 words 10 marks
Environment 15%
We have a target to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2030. Please provide evidence of how your organisation demonstrate sustainability principles. What measures and standards have you implemented to minimise your carbon footprint.
Ethical Employment 5%
CCDG has adopted the Welsh Government‘s code of practice on ethical procurement in supply chains.
Please describe how you will commit to fair working practices for workers engaged in the delivery of this contract (including any agency or sub-contracted workers
We would like to bring to the attention of our perspective suppliers guidance on the code of ethical supply chains as published by the Welsh Government.
https://gov.wales/topics/improvingservices/bettervfm/code-of-practice/?lang=en
Adopting the code voluntarily is not a requirement of this tender.
The above sections will be awarded marks based on the following criteria:
• Very good or fully compliant submission which meets all requirements and is fully explained in comprehensive detail - between 90 and 100% of the marks available
• Good or fully compliant submission, which meets all the requirements and is explained in reasonable detail - between 70% and 80% of the marks available.
• Satisfactory or compliant submission which meets the essential requirements and is explained in adequate detail - between 50% and 60% of the marks available.
• Weak or partially compliant submission where some areas fall short of requirements and poorly explained - between 30% and 40% of the marks available.
• Unacceptable or non-compliant (major issues) submission which fails to meet requirements and Is not explained- between 10% and 20% of the marks available.
|